What would biology say about that? To understand why aliens and humans wouldn’t probably be able to generate offspring, we need to review some biological concepts. But not all lookalike organisms belong to the same species. One example is the African fish eagle and the bald eagle. They look quite similar but they belong to different species. Dogs, on the other hand (paw?), come in different colors, shapes, and sizes — but they all belong to the same species. To explore this concept a little further, let’s take the mule as an example — the offspring of a female horse and a male donkey. In this case, two different species generated a viable offspring. So why we still consider horses and donkeys different species? The answer to that question is that the mule is infertile — it can’t generate its own offspring. Therefore, it didn’t meet all of the requirements for a successful reproduction: healthy, viable, and fertile. “Because members of a species can interbreed, the species as a whole has a common gene pool, a collection of gene variants. On the other hand, genes are not exchanged between different species. Even if organisms of different species combine their DNA to make offspring, the offspring will be sterile, unable to pass on their genes,” the Khan Academy explains. Speciation also has an important role in the evolutionary process. Different species have their own gene collection or gene pool. This prevents the exchange of genes and maintains species separated from each other during evolution. This process explains why we have a great variety of living organisms, each one playing its role in the ecosystem. If it weren’t for speciation, we would still be unicellular organisms swimming in the ocean.
Prezygotic barriers
Prezygotic barriers are barriers that prevent different species from mating. We can have:
Habitat isolation: when two species live in different habitats and are unlikely to encounter one another. Temporal isolation: when two species reproduce at different times of the day or year. Behavioral isolation: when two species have different mate preferences and may think that the other species is not attractive enough for them. Genetic isolation: when the egg and sperm from the two species can’t combine in fertilization. Mechanical isolation: when their bodies or reproductive systems are too different, and simply don’t fit together.
Postzygotic barriers
Those are barriers that prevent hybrid zygotes to develop into healthy, fertile adults. Sometimes, the mixture of the genetic material of the two species produces an abnormal genetic conformation in the zygote. The possibilities are:
The zygote can’t develop, killing off the embryo The individual can survive but with significant health issues The zygote will develop into a healthy organism that is infertile (e.g. the mule)
However, although nature is unable to produce viable, fertile offspring from members of different species, technology might change these rules of the road for nature. Recently, controversial research was conducted in China, involving a technique that allows editing the genome. This technique is called CRISPR-Cas9 and makes it possible to play with DNA, removing undesirable characteristics, editing, or inserting characteristics that did not exist before. The technique was used to generate a baby possibly immune to HIV. The scientist responsible for this, He Jiankui, was sentenced to prison for not respecting ethical standards in research. Another researcher, Juan Carlos Izpisua Belmonte, injected monkey embryos with human cells, creating the first human-monkey embryo. The main point of the research was to explore the possibility to grow human organs on animals for future transplants. “More babies produced using the CRISPR gene-editing technology are now planned by a scientist in Russia, where another researcher is also hoping to conduct the world’s first human head transplant. And Japan has recently lifted its own ban on human-animal hybrids,” David Lawrence writes for The Conversation. Coming from different planets, our two species would have evolved in radically different environments, so it would be very unlikely that alien life would resemble humans in most respects (although a few qualities might still be similar). Even if we were physically “compatible”, perhaps our genetic material would be different, which would make it impossible to generate offspring. Or, these descendants would be infertile — like mules. The only possibility for human evolution through alien hybrids would be through gene editing, but will it happen? The laws of biology and chemistry make this a possibility seem unlikely, but to rule out human-alien hybrids forever would be — illogical. This article was originally published on The Cosmic Companion by James Maynard, founder and publisher of The Cosmic Companion and Dr. Ana Luiza Dias. Astronomy News with The Cosmic Companion is also available as a weekly podcast, carried on all major podcast providers. Tune in every Tuesday for updates on the latest astronomy news, and interviews with astronomers and other researchers working to uncover the nature of the Universe.
